Written in Blood

For 35 years I worked in the Navy flight test community, alongside a lot of excellent test pilots. One of the sayings that was drummed into us is “The NATOPS manual is written in blood.” NATOPS stands for “Naval Air Training and Operating Procedures Standardization” – it’s a program to make sure that all United States Naval aviators and service members are well-trained and kept as safe as possible, by standardizing the safety procedures across the entire Naval Aviation community. In common parlance in the pilot community, the NATOPS manual is the shorthand name of the flight manual for every airplane.

So we have the saying that really means “the airplane flight manual is written in blood.” Well, not literally, of course. It’s typical ink on the printed page. But the real meaning is that the flight manual encapsulates all the hard-won learning about what typically injures and kills people, and it’s captured in the manual so that those who faithfully follow its instructions are much less likely to be injured or killed themselves. There are plenty of Naval Aviators and maintenance technicians who lost a friend and coworker in a mishap, and there are plenty of paragraphs and sections in the NATOPS manual that are there because somebody died or was injured doing something.

That’s a pretty verbose way of saying that we have to learn from our mistakes. The best way to avoid making those mistakes in the future is to carefully record what went wrong, and pass that knowledge down to those who follow us.

But simply passing the knowledge down isn’t enough. It takes some enforcement and careful monitoring.

Another principle one learns as a young flight test engineer is called the “normalization of deviance.” It’s a sociological term that talks about the creeping growth of unsafe practices. When one ignores a rule and nothing bad happens, eventually that deviation from the rules becomes normalized. After a while, another rule will be ignored, then another. But nobody notices the change, because it’s gradual, and nothing bad is happening – yet.

You probably have heard the analogy of a frog in a pot of water. You can turn on the heat, and the frog never jumps out, because the temperature rises slowly enough that it doesn’t perceive the danger until it’s too late. The frog’s danger sense is thinking something like “oh, it’s only a degree warmer. That’s not dangerous. I still feel the same. Nothing bad happened. I can keep sitting here.” But at some point, the frog is boiled alive.

If you look up the term “normalization of deviance,” you’ll quickly learn that it became very relevant in the investigation of the Challenger Space Shuttle explosion in 1986. The engineers knew about the risks of cold weather, but over time, they’d started to ignore one thing after another, because nothing bad had happened so far. So over some years, many of the carefully-crafted safety rules were gradually lost in practice – they were on the books but ignored. Eventually, the “holes in the Swiss cheese” lined up – all the risks aligned to let the worst case through the defenses – and a mishap occurred, one that killed a group of astronauts and shut down the entire Space Shuttle program for some time.

So it’s not enough to learn lessons, or to carefully document them. You also have to diligently attend to them, and resist the urge to let the deviation become normalized.

I’m thinking about this today in light of the recent 2026 midterm elections, and the political climate in America right now. And I’m specifically also thinking about the lessons that the world learned in World War II about fascism and strong men, and the lessons that we should have learned about how a large segment of the German church swooned over Hitler’s rise to power, hoping he would give them an authoritarian strongman who had promised to promote “positive Christianity.”

While as a progressive Christian and a political liberal I was thrilled by the outcome of the midterm elections, and recognizing that things went dramatically better than I could have hoped, I’m still deeply worried about the future of our nation. Over the last 80 years, many of the hard-won lessons from the 1930s through the 1940s have been normalized away. Those lessons were literally written in blood – the blood of many millions of lives lost to Hitler’s atrocities: not just Jewish lives, but countless other soldiers and civilians around the world who died fighting the war which spread across the globe.

In particular, here’s what’s worrying me right now. I’m seeing a lot of people calling for simply moving on – now that the Democrats gained so many seats in Congress and in state governments around the country, they can just start governing and pretend the right wing doesn’t exist. But that’s ignoring one lesson that I fear is critical to remember from 1945: people who have committed gross crimes and indecencies against their fellow humans must be held accountable. The Nuremberg trials were essential to the post World War II recovery: numerous Nazis and collaborators who could be identified were charged and convicted and punished. But shockingly, although over 100,000 people were investigated by West German prosecutors, only about 6,500 were convicted. And many churches lobbied for clemency even for them.

There was a very real cost of not being thorough in the prosecution of those who had committed Nazi atrocities. Victims were expected to return to normal life alongside those who had abused them and even murdered their neighbors and friends and relatives. Former Nazis ended up returning to the courts and law enforcement and even clergy. It took many decades to clean up the mess.

Churches played a key role in this process, too, with their calls for mercy and clemency. They wanted to find a faster way to return to a stable democracy, a normal way of life. One might argue that a harsher purge of the evildoers would have disrupted society even more. But as followers of Jesus, we ought to understand the risks of “cheap grace,” as the Nazi’s chief Christian opponent Dietrich Bonhoeffer called it: forgiveness without discipleship, without any change. No requirement for confession or repentance or restitution does nothing to bring healing; it only brings an uncomfortable stagnation where the wounded are still living under the gun, wondering if the offender will act again. And those who got away with their crimes won’t learn any critical lessons about how people in a free and decent society ought to live together.

So with all of that in mind, we ought to think very carefully about how we should act in the months ahead. I’m still nervous about the next couple months, with an actual transfer of power from the election losers to the winners. There will be many ways that could go horribly wrong. But even if it goes well – in fact, especially if it goes well – the worst thing we can do is pretend that 2024-2026 didn’t happen. That’s because the way we should handle a bloody lesson is to memorialize it, remember it, and write it down in a durable format, so that we don’t have to learn that lesson again in such a bloody manner.

The last two years have been deeply painful for many people, and even deadly for many. Let us learn from our national mistakes, and vow never to repeat them. And the best way we can do that is to hold the perpetrators accountable for every single violation of the law and violation of human rights.

Right away, I imagine a rebuttal that this is being vindictive or seeking revenge. No, it’s not. Many people have suffered great harm from very illegal conduct in the last couple years, by a great many agents of the American government. Many laws have been broken, from the President all the way down to ICE agents and other low-level functionaries. Every single crime ought to be investigated and prosecuted. It’ll be slow and expensive, but I believe it’s necessary to restore our nation. America has always been founded on a system of respect for law, as is true of any functioning democratic nation. If you stop enforcing the laws, anarchy and despotism are the certain result, in very short order.

So let’s not forget the lessons that were written in blood 80 years ago, let’s not normalize the deviation from our laws and Constitution, and be diligent to preserve the moral and legal framework on which our nation was founded. We owe it to our children, to leave them a functioning nation.

If you liked this article, then please follow us on Bluesky logo and or join our email notification list.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top